The Key Differences Between Options and Stocks

If you are an experienced stock trader who is anxious to get involved with trading options, I must issue one stern warning: Options are not stocks.

Some consider themselves to be pure traders and believe they can trade anything. It doesn’t matter whether it’s stock, options, futures, currencies etc. I don’t believe that. Options are easy to understand, but are far more complicated to trade.

It’s reasonable to assume that everyone has access to all information concerning a stock. Given that information, some are buyers, some are sellers, and some avoid the stock. Supply and demand determines whether the stock moves higher or lower. Some may buy or sell, taking advantage (it’s against the law) of inside information, but in general, no one has any special advantage over anyone else. What separates one trader/investor from another is better judgment.

Fundamental analysts know what’s going on with earnings, sales etc. Technical analysts have the same data, but may be using different software to evaluate future prospects for the stock. Either of these analysts may ‘discover’ an edge that encourages the purchase or sale of stock.

But option prices depend on far more than supply and demand. When markets are generally calm, option prices tend to decrease. When markets are volatile, option prices tend to increase. And that’s true for puts and calls.

3 Major Differences between Stocks and Options:

1. Options expire. Stocks last forever (unless the company goes bankrupt).

2. Options are derivative products. Their value is derived from the value of another asset. Stocks are assets, and have an intrinsic value.

3. Option owners have rights, but do not own anything tangible. Stock owners are entitled to dividends and own a share of the company.

Trading Differences

1. Stock prices depend on supply and demand, and move accordingly.

2. Option prices depend on many factors, each of which affects the price of an option in the marketplace.

  • The price of the underlying asset. As the asset moves higher, calls move higher, puts move lower
  • The type of option. Calls move in the same direction as the underlying asset (they have positive delta) and puts move in the opposite direction (they have negative delta).
  • The time to expiration. All options lose value as time passes.
  • The prevailing interest rates. As interest rates increase, calls increase in value (but only by a small amount, unless there is a lot of time before the option expires). Puts decrease in value as interest rates rise.
  • The strike price. The lower an option’s strike price, the more a call option is worth. The higher the strike price, the more a put option is worth.
  • The dividend paid by the underlying asset. A high dividend reduces the value of a call and increases the value of a put.
  • Volatility. This is the crucial factor in determining the price of an option. Each of the other factors involved in an option’s price is known with certainty. But the volatility estimate used to calculate the value of an option refers to the future volatility. Specifically: how volatile is the stock going to be between the time the option is purchased and the time it expires? Because the future is unknown, the volatility component of an option’s price can only be estimated. Different people make different estimates, and thus, each has a different idea as to the value of an option. If you notice options changing price when the stock doesn’t move (or vice versa) it’s likely due to a change in the volatility estimate.

Mark Wolfinger is a 20 year CBOE options veteran and is the writer for the blog Options for Rookies Premium. He also is the author of the book, The Rookie’s Guide to Options.

Further Reading, Options:

Join 17,000 Investors

Receive Daily Market Recaps directly in your email inbox!

Log, Store, and Analyze Your Trades

Whether you're a new or seasoned investor, the Trade Journal helps you trade better:
  • Step 1 - Add trades
  • Step 2 - Mark strategies and mistakes
  • Step 3 - Analyze your results
  • Step 4 - Improve your trading
Get Started Now